Public health’s hardest job is explaining what we don’t know. The global hantavirus outbreak highlights one of the hardest tasks in public health: communicating uncertainty without creating either panic or false reassurance. That challenge becomes especially difficult during outbreaks caused by rare pathogens, where scientific evidence is limited, the number of historical cases is small, and the pressure to provide immediate guidance is intense.
There has been extensive media coverage and public discussion recently about the outbreak of the Andes virus strain of hantavirus aboard the M/V Hondius cruise ship. Public discussion has been divided into familiar camps. Some warn that public health agencies are overreacting and preparing for more lockdowns and quarantines. Others argue the opposite, insisting agencies are underestimating the risk of airborne spread and failing to impose sufficiently strict controls.
Both reactions lack nuance. The central issue is less whether hantavirus should be labeled “the next pandemic,” and more whether public health agencies are preparing the public sufficiently for how to act now and how to act when our evidence changes.
The Responsibilities of Public Health Agencies
Public health agencies have a responsibility to provide practical answers even before the science is fully settled. People want to know answers to questions, such as: Am I at risk from a family member? Should I wear a mask? Is it safe to travel? What precautions are worth taking?
At the same time, public health experts need to express humility. They need to be sufficiently transparent about what we know, what we suspect, and what remains uncertain. Outbreaks of uncommon infectious diseases expose the certainty of our knowledge and make us question our assumptions. Hantavirus is a perfect example of this.
Fair Use Notice
UNMC Global Center for Health Security staff curate publicly available news and information for educational and informational purposes. Brief excerpts of published articles may be displayed under principles of Fair Use, with credit and links provided to the source publications. All copyrights remain the property of their respective owners.